THETRINUNITYPROJECT
Study contents

The Totality of God · PART IV · How Do We Know What God Is Doing

God Told Me

Central question: How should we evaluate claims about personal guidance or divine explanation?

Key Scriptures: ; ; ; ;

A claim of divine authority carries weight

“God told me” can describe a person’s strong conviction, but it can also make a statement difficult to question. If someone claims divine authority for a decision that affects other people, those people may feel that disagreement is disobedience to God. That is why the wording matters.

Distinguish what Scripture clearly teaches from what a person believes God may be guiding them to do. “This passage commands honesty” identifies a textual claim that can be examined. “I believe this may be a wise step” leaves room for judgment. “God told me you must do this” places a much heavier burden on someone else.

The Bible commands testing

First tells believers to test spiritual claims in relation to the truth about Jesus Christ and apostolic teaching. combines openness with examination: believers are to test and retain what is good. Neither passage supports automatic acceptance merely because a message sounds spiritual.

commends examination of the Scriptures in response to teaching. This is not hostility toward God. It is a faithful way to evaluate claims made in his name. Testing should involve reading passages in context rather than selecting a verse that happens to resemble the desired outcome.

Examine content manner and accountability

Ask what is being claimed, which passage supports it, and whether that passage actually addresses the matter. Then examine the way the claim is used. Does the person welcome careful questions? Do they take responsibility if their prediction fails? Are they asking for money, control, secrecy, or compliance that serves their interests?

describes wisdom in terms that include peaceableness, gentleness, and openness to reason. A pleasant manner alone does not prove a claim true, but refusal of accountability is a serious problem. Spiritual language does not excuse coercion or make evidence unnecessary.

Do not confuse perception with interpretation

A person may notice a concern without knowing its cause. “I feel uneasy” reports an experience. “This teaching may contradict Scripture” proposes an interpretation that can be examined. “A demon is behind this person” claims something far more specific. Each step requires its own grounds.

The same care applies to explanations of tragedy. A strong feeling that one understands God’s purpose does not establish that purpose. It is often more truthful to say, “I see this possible connection, but I may be mistaken.” Humility protects people from carrying another person’s untested certainty.

Exercises and discussion

Four questions for reflection

Name what you see. Identify what remains unknown. Read the relevant Scripture in context. State what you can trust and one faithful response. Keep observations, interpretations, and promises distinct.

Discussion topics

1. How can “God told me” change the pressure placed on a listener?

2. What do the testing passages require us to examine?

3. How does help evaluate the way a claim is presented?

4. Where might you need to distinguish an observation from an interpretation?

Exercise 1 Scripture and personal application

Take one spiritual claim you have encountered. Write its exact content, the evidence offered, and the relevant Scripture in context. Note what remains unverified. If it concerns a decision, express your present judgment in language that leaves room for correction. You do not owe immediate compliance to an untested claim.

Exercise 2 Discuss and test

Work with a partner or group on discussion question 1. Identify the passage that supports your answer, a conclusion the passage does not support, and a practical response. If studying alone, write both your answer and a possible objection, then examine each against the text.

In conclusion

Claims made in God’s name deserve careful examination. Testing honors Scripture and protects the community. We can welcome God’s work without assigning his authority to every impression, prediction, or proposed explanation.

Closing prayer

God of truth, keep us attentive and discerning. Give us humility when speaking and courage when asking questions. Protect us from manipulation and from our own overconfidence. Let your revealed word govern the claims we make. Amen.

SCRIPTURE · KING JAMES VERSION

Read the surrounding context and compare with your preferred Bible translation.
THE TRINUNITY PROJECT

Contact the author

Your email address lets the author reply.